Mexican First Lady Angélica Rivera has returned the US$7 million mansion she bought from a firm that won lucrative contracts with the administration of President Enrique Peña Nieto, Mexico's Public Administration Department said Friday. The department's head said neither the president nor his wife had incurred in any conflicts of interest.
But investigation headed by Virgilio Andrade apparently consisted largely of asking government employees whether they had steered contracts to the firm, and critics have questioned Andrade's independence because he was appointed by the president himself.
After a scandal erupted in 2014 amid news reports about the property, Rivera said in November that she was buying the house from the company on monthly payments with money she earned as an actress. The company was to hold title to the mansion until it was paid off.
Rivera said she would sell her rights to the property after questions arose about the president's relationship with contractor Grupo Higa. The mansion was built by one of contractor's subsidiaries.
Just days before the news reports surfaced, Peña Nieto's government canceled a high-speed rail contract that had been granted to the sole bidder, a consortium that included Constructora Teya, another Grupo Higa company. Competitors complained the bidding process had been rushed.
Andrade said Friday that Rivera had reached an agreement with the Grupo Higa subsidiary to pay about US$635,000 (10.5 million pesos) in rent for the nearly three years she used the property.
The company agreed to return about US$875,000 (14.5 million pesos) she had made in payments on the mansion.
Andrade said the investigation showed that Rivera had bought the house before Peña Nieto took office in December 2012, and that there was no evidence that Peña Nieto intervened to steer contracts to the company.
Doubts have surrounded Andrade's investigation, in part because of his lack of independence; Peña Nieto appointed him in February to investigate his own administration.
Andrade's investigation apparently consisted largely of asking Peña Nieto's office if he intervened in awarding contracts, and asking 111 government employees if anyone had pressured them into awarding contracts. He refused to answer reporters' questions about whether he had checked the employees' email accounts.
At a three-hour news conference, Andrade refused to answer questions about why Grupo Higa's rail contract was cancelled just days before the mansion scandal broke.
While the government initially offered to have a panel of independent experts review the investigation, Andrade said he had decided not to convene such a panel but instead to post the documents on a government website.
"The important thing is that there is full access for everybody," he said.
